Manufacturing News
November 22, 2026
November 22, 2026 · Tipton County · Story 1 of 5
7th Circuit Shields High Performance Alloys' Insurer After Windfall Worker's Death
The 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Insurance Company of the West has no duty to defend High Performance Alloys, a Windfall, Indiana metal alloys manufacturer, in the death of metalworker Elliott Sullivan. IOSHA had cited the plant for an "ineffectively guarded" grinder in 2022, seven months before Sullivan died on the same type of equipment. The court rejected the estate's argument that the prior citation met Indiana's "substantial certainty" standard for piercing workers' comp exclusivity, and declined to send that open legal question to the Indiana Supreme Court. IOSHA's total regulatory consequence across both the 2022 citation and the fatality was $14,000. Civil tort exposure against the employer stays blocked unless intent rises to the "deliberate" standard set in Baker v. Westinghouse, a bar the 7th Circuit left untested at the state level.
- Impact
- IOSHA's total regulatory consequence for a fatality at a facility with a documented prior guarding violation was $14,000 ($7,000 for the 2022 citation, $7,000 after Sullivan's death) and this ruling confirms civil tort exposure stays blocked unless intent rises to Indiana's 'deliberate' standard under Baker v. Westinghouse. Because the 7th Circuit refused to certify that question, Indiana state courts could still rule differently, leaving plaintiffs' attorneys a narrow opening to pursue product-liability suits against equipment makers instead of employers. For Indiana's metalworking and foundry cluster, the case functions as a de facto underwriting subsidy that reduces financial pressure to accelerate machine-guarding capex.
- Watch
- Whether an Indiana state court case tests the uncertified 'substantial certainty' question under Baker v. Westinghouse, since the 7th Circuit left it unresolved.
- For the huddle
If our last IOSHA 'serious' citation on a guarding issue is still open, what would it actually cost us in civil exposure (not just the fine) if a worker were killed on that same machine tomorrow?
Right now in Indiana, workers' comp exclusivity holds unless intent rises to the "deliberate" standard under Baker v. Westinghouse, and the 7th Circuit just confirmed a prior IOSHA citation alone doesn't clear that bar. That question hasn't been tested in an Indiana state court yet, so treat the current protection as the law today, not a guarantee it stays that way.
Sources
- Workers’ Comp Exclusivity Proves Tough as Steel in Metalworker’s Death Case · workerscompensation.com
From the brief, November 22, 2026
- 7th Circuit Shields High Performance Alloys' Insurer After Windfall Worker's Death
- Panduit's $76.5 Million Merrillville Investment Turns Illinois Losses Into Lake County Gains
- Eli Lilly's GLP-1 Surge Backs the $4.5 Billion Lebanon Build-Out
- Ohio's Chip Worker Pipeline Faces a Timing Mismatch Before Intel Even Opens
- Google Pays $10.8 Million to Jump Columbus's Transmission Queue, A Template AEP's Indiana Utility Could Replicate
This story
Related
- Gary Works' $4.5 Billion Investment Locks In Through 2030 as Steel Tariffs Face a 2027 Test
- Weyland's $11 Million Elberfeld Plant, Purdue-Evonik's $100 Million Lafayette Deal, and the AES Indiana Rate Case BlackRock Just Reopened
- Simtra's $250M Bloomington Expansion, I&M's Rate Cut, and Rising Data Center Electricity Demand: Five Updates Indiana Manufacturers Need This Week
Manufacturers Energy Grant Program
Free for Tipton County manufacturers
Tipton County manufacturers receive free, ongoing energy auditing and cost control that reduces their energy bills and keeps them low, month after month. Every line item checked and validated, every opportunity found comes with a step-by-step guide to capture it.
EDCs: sponsor this program and it carries your organization's name For economic developers →

